| Name, Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
| Noah Trister, The Associated Press | BAL | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | Valdez |
| Steve Melewski, MASNSports.com | BAL | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | McClanahan |
| Christopher Smith, MassLive.com | BOS | Verlander | Manoah | Cease | Ohtani | McClanahan |
| Chad Jennings, The Athletic | BOS | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | McClanahan |
| James Fegan, The Athletic | CHI | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | Valdez |
| LaMond Pope, Chicago Tribune | CHI | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | McClanahan |
| Zack Meisel, The Athletic | CLE | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | Bieber |
| Joe Noga, cleveland.com | CLE | Verlander | Ohtani | Manoah | Bieber | Cease |
| Evan Woodbery, Mlive Media Group | DET | Verlander | Ohtani | Manoah | Cease | Bieber |
| Chris McCosky, Detroit News | DET | Verlander | Cease | Ohtani | Manoah | Cortes |
| Kristie Rieken, The Associated Press | HOU | Verlander | Cease | Ohtani | Manoah | Valdez |
| Brian McTaggart, MLB.com | HOU | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Valdez | Bieber |
| Jen McCaffrey, The Athletic | KC | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | Valdez |
| Lynn Worthy, Kansas City Star | KC | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | McClanahan | Ohtani |
| Yuichi Matsushita, Kyodo News | LA | Verlander | Ohtani | Manoah | Cease | Valdez |
| Rhett Bollinger, MLB.com | LA | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | Valdez |
| Do-Hyoung Park, MLB.com | MIN | Verlander | Cease | Manoah | Ohtani | Valdez |
| Aaron Gleeman, The Athletic | MIN | Verlander | Cease | Ohtani | Manoah | Valdez |
| Randy Miller, NJ Advance Media | NY | Verlander | Manoah | Ohtani | Cease | Cortes |
| Bryan Hoch, MLB.com | NY | Verlander | Manoah | Cease | Ohtani | Cortes |
| Martín Gallegos, MLB.com | OAK | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | Valdez |
| Eno Sarris, The Athletic | OAK | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | McClanahan |
| Ryan Divish, Seattle Times | SEA | Verlander | Ohtani | Cease | Manoah | Valdez |
| Larry Stone, Seattle Times | SEA | Verlander | Cease | Ohtani | Manoah | Valdez |
| Mark Didtler, Associated Press | TB | Verlander | Manoah | Cease | Ohtani | McClanahan |
| John Romano, Tampa Bay Times | TB | Verlander | Manoah | Cease | Ohtani | McClanahan |
Copyright © 2024 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.
