A breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the American League.
| Name, | Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| Dave Ginsburg, The Associated Press | BAL | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Witt | Jr. |
| Rich Dubroff, BaltimoreBaseball.com | BAL | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| David Laurila, FanGraphs | BOS | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Rob Bradford, WEEI.com | BOS | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Scott Gregor, Daily Herald | CHI | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Scott Merkin, MLB.com | CHI | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Tom Withers, The Associated Press | CLE | Rodriguez | Kwan | Witt | Jr. |
| Anthony Castrovince, MLB.com | CLE | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Jason Beck, MLB.com | DET | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Evan Woodbery, MLive Media Group | DET | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Alyson Footer, MLB.com | HOU | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Pena | |
| Kristie Rieken, The Associated Press | HOU | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kirby | |
| David Brown, Bally Sports | KC | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Vahe Gregorian, Kansas City Star | KC | Rodriguez | Witt | Jr. | Pena |
| Nobuhiro Saito, Nikkan Sports News | LA | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Jeff Fletcher, OC Register | LA | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Dave Campbell, The Associated Press | MIN | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Dan Hayes, The Athletic | MIN | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Pete Caldera, Bergen Record | NY | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Erik Boland, New York Newsday | NY | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Steve Kroner, San Francisco Chronicle | OAK | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Melissa Lockard, The Athletic | OAK | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Witt | Jr. |
| Matt Calkins, Seattle Times | SEA | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Tim Booth, The Associated Press | SEA | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Adam Berry, MLB.com | TB | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Mark Topkin, Tampa Bay Times | TB | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman | |
| Evan Grant, Dallas Morning News | TEX | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Jaeho Kim, MK Sports | TEX | Rodriguez | Rutschman | Kwan | |
| Ben Nicholson-Smith, Sportsnet.ca | TOR | Rutschman | Rodriguez | Witt | Jr. |
| Scott Mitchell, TSN | TOR | Rodriguez | Kwan | Rutschman |
Copyright © 2024 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.
