Old Georgetown Theater gets new life as commercial space

Georgetown Then.  Dumbarton Theater, 1913. Courtesy DC Public Library, Washingtoniana Division
Georgetown then: The Dumbarton Theater, 1913. (Courtesy DC Public Library, Washingtoniana Division)
Architect Robert Bell holds a piece of pressed tin cornice from the Georgetown Theater site. It probably dates back to the time when the theater was called the Dumbarton, in the early 1900s. Next to him is a model of the theater and other buildings on the block. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
Architect Robert Bell holds a piece of pressed tin cornice from the Georgetown Theater site. It probably dates back to the time when the theater was called the Dumbarton, in the early 1900s. Next to him is a model of the theater and other buildings on the block. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
What the Georgetown Theater building looks like today at Wisconsin and O streets. Plans are to install a new vertical neon sign soon. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
What the Georgetown Theater building looks like today at Wisconsin Avenue and O Street. Plans are to install a new vertical neon sign soon. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
New windows are being added on the  building's south side that will bring in more light. Notice the two different  colors of brick? Brick that was already part of the site was re-used to build up the top floor. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
New windows are being added on the  building’s south side that will bring in more light. Notice the two different  colors of brick? Brick that was already part of the site was re-used to build up the top floor. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
The view over Wisconsin Avenue and up O Street from the theater building’s second floor, which will become office space. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)

The future and the past

A photo posted by Robert Bell Architects (@robert_bell_architects) on

(WTOP/Michelle Basch)

Choosing the neon gas and tubing-#georgetown theater

A photo posted by Robert Bell Architects (@robert_bell_architects) on

(WTOP/Michelle Basch)
(WTOP/Michelle Basch)
(1/8)
Georgetown Then.  Dumbarton Theater, 1913. Courtesy DC Public Library, Washingtoniana Division
Architect Robert Bell holds a piece of pressed tin cornice from the Georgetown Theater site. It probably dates back to the time when the theater was called the Dumbarton, in the early 1900s. Next to him is a model of the theater and other buildings on the block. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
What the Georgetown Theater building looks like today at Wisconsin and O streets. Plans are to install a new vertical neon sign soon. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)
New windows are being added on the  building's south side that will bring in more light. Notice the two different  colors of brick? Brick that was already part of the site was re-used to build up the top floor. (WTOP/Michelle Basch)

WASHINGTON — An old movie theater in our area is being brought back to life to serve a new purpose, and WTOP got a behind-the-scenes tour.

The Georgetown Theater, on Wisconsin Avenue at O Street in Northwest, stopped showing movies in the 1980s and was converted into a store. The theater’s big vertical “Georgetown” sign, once an impressive landmark, was left to rot.

“It was basically the most degenerated building in all of Georgetown or all of Wisconsin Avenue,” says architect Robert Bell. “I’ve been trying for seven years to either paint the front (or) restore the neon sign to make it look like it’s part of the neighborhood.”

He finally bought the building last year.  Although the outside of the building will soon look more like a theater than it has in years, no movies will be shown inside. It’s being converted to create commercial space on the first floor, offices on the second and apartments on the third.

Just recently, the fake stone front that was added to the theater about 65 years ago was removed. “We discovered underneath it, this beautiful facade,” Bell says.

As for the iconic theater sign, Bell removed it and had it lovingly and painstakingly re-created by the same company that originally made it. His plan is to install it in a few weeks and hold a lighting ceremony in September.

Bell says the building will be highly energy-efficient, and he’s using a bunch of recycled materials. For instance, bricks that were removed to create windows were re-used to build up the third floor.

Interestingly, the construction there has uncovered glimpses of what the place looked like when it was a silent movie theater called the Dumbarton in the early 1900s. Bell has found small sections of brick arches hinting at the theater’s elaborate former facade, as well a single piece of pressed tin cornice for a tin ceiling.

“In probably the original theater, this went all along the top of the roof. This is the only piece that survived,” he says.

“If you talk to people who went here in the ’50s, they’ll [say] that the center of Georgetown was not Wisconsin and M; it was O and Wisconsin. It was the theater,” Bell says.

He thinks this part of Georgetown will once again become a busy hub: “Good architecture will transform the whole area.”

D.C.’s first cat cafe, Crumbs & Whiskers, recently opened on O Street just steps away from the theater.

You can read more about the theater’s history here.

Michelle Basch

Michelle Basch is a reporter turned morning anchor at WTOP News.

Federal News Network Logo
Log in to your WTOP account for notifications and alerts customized for you.

Sign up