Exclusive: After taking in kids orphaned by murder-suicide, Md. family asks for help

Investigators served a protective order to Calvin Carnathan hours after his wife filed it before a District Court judge Friday, January 26. The next day the couple was found dead. (Courtesy Carnathan family)
Investigators served a protective order to Calvin Carnathan hours after his wife filed it before a District Court judge Friday, January 26. The next day the couple was found dead.

Candace Carnathan's younger sister, Sydney Miles, said she was on the phone with her sister when she asked her husband, Calvin, to remove his shotgun from the home. (Courtesy Carnathan family)
Candace Carnathan’s younger sister, Sydney Miles, said she was on the phone with her sister (pictured) when she asked her husband, Calvin, to remove his shotgun from the home. (Courtesy Carnathan family)

(1/2)
Investigators served a protective order to Calvin Carnathan hours after his wife filed it before a District Court judge Friday, January 26. The next day the couple was found dead. (Courtesy Carnathan family)
Candace Carnathan's younger sister, Sydney Miles, said she was on the phone with her sister when she asked her husband, Calvin, to remove his shotgun from the home. (Courtesy Carnathan family)

WASHINGTON — Nearly a month after investigators say a White Plains man killed his wife and turned the gun on himself, their three orphaned children are left to pick up the pieces.

Candace Carnathan, 33, sought a protective order against her husband the day before the shooting. Now, her family is asking for help from the community in supporting the couple’s kids.

“Since they first got together, that’s one thing he’d always say, is that he was going to kill himself,” said Sydney Miles, Candace Carnathan’s younger sister.

Miles doesn’t know whether her brother-in-law was mentally ill, but said he would often threaten to take his life in what seemed to be an attempt to manipulate his wife.

“We all became immune to it … and then the next day he would, of course, be OK,” Miles said. “So it was a shock to all of this that this is what had happened.”

Calvin Carnathan killed his wife of 12 years on Jan. 27 while their three children were home, the Charles County Sheriff’s Department said. It was the day after she got a protective order, reporting that Calvin slapped her and had been tracking her movements. She marked in three places on the protective order petition that her husband Calvin had access to a shotgun, according to court documents.

Miles confirmed the same gun was used in her murder. A judge did not mandate sheriff’s deputies to confiscate the weapon in issuing the order.

“I think [it was] the fact that she wanted to remove him from her. It wasn’t about the kids. It wasn’t about the house. It was he was being told to leave her alone and not to contact her … and I think that’s what made him snap,” Miles said.

Calvin Carnathan had no prior violent offenses in Maryland, and Capt. Stephen Salvas, with the sheriff’s department, said Carnathan left peacefully when he was served the protective order at the family home in White Plains the evening of Jan. 26.

Miles spoke with Calvin the night before the shooting.

“And his words were, ‘I’m not going to hurt anyone. I would never hurt your sister. I love her. She’s my world. If anything, I’d just harm myself,'” Miles said.

Miles and Candace’s older sister, Stevonna, has four children of her own. She’s adopted her nephews and niece and set up an online fundraiser for their counseling and education.

“They’re 11, 10 and 7, and they all have birthdays coming up,” she said. “So, we’re just trying to keep everything together, and keep them together and make sure they are OK.”


Like WTOP on Facebook and follow @WTOP on Twitter to engage in conversation about this article and others.

© 2018 WTOP. All Rights Reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

More from WTOP

Log in to your WTOP account for notifications and alerts customized for you.

Sign up