Drawing declares Yancey winner of disputed Va. House race; Simonds doesn’t concede

 

WASHINGTON — Republican David Yancey won a drawing to break a tie in the disputed 94th District race in Newport News Thursday however his opponent is expected to challenge the decision, possibly seeking yet another recount.

Control of the House of Delegates is at stake. A win by Yancey in the race would give Republicans enough votes to pick the next speaker when it meets on Wednesday.

A disappointed Shelly Simonds told reporters that she is not giving up and that all options are still on the table for the Democrat. She said previously that she may seek a second recount, a contest in the House of Delegates or “other legal options.”

“At this moment, I am not conceding,” she said.

Yancey, the incumbent Delegate for the seat, did not make the trip to Richmond for the 11 a.m. drawing, however several Republican staffers attended.

The candidates’ names were written on slips of paper and placed in black film canisters, which election officials said were ordered fresh from Amazon for the occasion.

The State Board of Elections used a blue, stoneware bowl created by Virginia artist Steven Glass for the important drawing.

The canisters were swirled and one selected from the bowl by Board Chair James Alcorn.

State law calls for tie elections to be decided by “drawing lots” — a process that is used on a regular basis to decide the ballot order for elections in the state. But the last drawing to break a tie in a House pf Delegates race was held in 1971.

Never before, however, has a tie determined who would be the speaker of the House. “Today we have witnessed an unprecedented event in the history of the Commonwealth of Virginia, said Board member Clara Belle Wheeler.

The decision comes after a reversal of fortunes for both candidates.

Democratic candidate for the 94th House of Delegates seat, Shelly Simonds, right, speaks to the media as her husband, Paul Danehy, left, and daughter, Georgia Danehy, center, look on after a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Republican Delegate David Yancey won the drawing. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
Democratic candidate for the 94th House of Delegates seat, Shelly Simonds, right, speaks to the media as her husband, Paul Danehy, left, and daughter, Georgia Danehy, center, look on after a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Republican Delegate David Yancey won the drawing. (AP Photo/Steve Helber) (AP/Steve Helber)
Virginia State Board of Elections chairman, James Alcorn, holds up the name of David Yancy, the winner of a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election for the 94th district House of Delegates seat at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Yancey won the drawing over Democrat Shelly Simonds. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
Virginia State Board of Elections chairman, James Alcorn, holds up the name of David Yancy, the winner of a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election for the 94th district House of Delegates seat at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Yancey won the drawing over Democrat Shelly Simonds. (AP Photo/Steve Helber) (AP/Steve Helber)
The certificate of election naming David Yancey the winner in 94th District House race on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 almost two months after the November election. A blue stoneware vessel created by Virginia artisit Stephen Glass was used for the drawing along with two new film canisters. (WTOP/Max Smith)
The certificate of election naming David Yancey the winner in 94th District House race is seen in Richmond. Yancey’s name was drawn from a bowl on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 naming him the winner almost two months after the November election. A blue stoneware vessel created by Virginia artisit Stephen Glass was used for the drawing along with two new film canisters. (WTOP/Max Smith) (WTOP/Max Smith)
Democrat Shelly Simonds awaits a drawing to determine the winner in the disputed 94th District House race on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 in Richmond. (WTOP/Max Smith)
Democrat Shelly Simonds awaits a drawing to determine the winner in the disputed 94th District House race on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 in Richmond. (WTOP/Max Smith) (WTOP/Max Smith)
Virginia Board of Elections chairman James Alcorn shows off the blue stoneware blue used in the drawing to break a tie in the disputed 94th District House Race on Jan. 4, 2018, in Richmond, Virginia. Virginia artist Steven Glass crafted the vessel, which represents the sky on the outside of the bowl and the oxide red inside represents the earth. (WTOP/Max Smith)
Virginia Board of Elections chairman James Alcorn shows off the blue stoneware used in the drawing to break a tie in the disputed 94th District House Race on Jan. 4, 2018, in Richmond, Virginia. Virginia artist Steven Glass crafted the vessel. The blue exterior of the bowl represents the sky and the red oxide inside represents the earth. (WTOP/Max Smith) (WTOP/Max Smith)
Two film canisters, which election officials said were ordered new from Amazon, and the names of the candidates printed on slips of paper await a drawing to break a tie in the 94th House race in Newport News. The drawing in Richmond declared Republican David Yancey the winner on Jan. 4, 2018 almost two months after the November election.  (WTOP/Max Smith)
Two film canisters, which election officials said were ordered new from Amazon, and the names of the candidates printed on slips of paper await a drawing to break a tie in the 94th House race in Newport News. The drawing in Richmond declared Republican David Yancey the winner on Jan. 4, 2018 almost two months after the November election. (WTOP/Max Smith) (WTOP/Max Smith)
(1/6)
Democratic candidate for the 94th House of Delegates seat, Shelly Simonds, right, speaks to the media as her husband, Paul Danehy, left, and daughter, Georgia Danehy, center, look on after a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Republican Delegate David Yancey won the drawing. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
Virginia State Board of Elections chairman, James Alcorn, holds up the name of David Yancy, the winner of a drawing to determine the winner of a tied election for the 94th district House of Delegates seat at the Capitol in Richmond, Va., Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018. Yancey won the drawing over Democrat Shelly Simonds. (AP Photo/Steve Helber)
The certificate of election naming David Yancey the winner in 94th District House race on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 almost two months after the November election. A blue stoneware vessel created by Virginia artisit Stephen Glass was used for the drawing along with two new film canisters. (WTOP/Max Smith)
Democrat Shelly Simonds awaits a drawing to determine the winner in the disputed 94th District House race on Thursday, Jan. 4, 2018 in Richmond. (WTOP/Max Smith)
Virginia Board of Elections chairman James Alcorn shows off the blue stoneware blue used in the drawing to break a tie in the disputed 94th District House Race on Jan. 4, 2018, in Richmond, Virginia. Virginia artist Steven Glass crafted the vessel, which represents the sky on the outside of the bowl and the oxide red inside represents the earth. (WTOP/Max Smith)
Two film canisters, which election officials said were ordered new from Amazon, and the names of the candidates printed on slips of paper await a drawing to break a tie in the 94th House race in Newport News. The drawing in Richmond declared Republican David Yancey the winner on Jan. 4, 2018 almost two months after the November election.  (WTOP/Max Smith)

Yancey appeared to be the winner in the race after Election Day, nearly two months ago. Then Simonds believed she had won the race by one vote the day ballots were recounted. The next day, a three-judge recount court counted one additional ballot for Yancey, creating the tie in the race at 11,608 votes.

Despite big gains by Democrats in the November election, Republicans are likely to control the House by a margin of 51-49, giving them the ability to set rules, pick committee chairs and ultimately decide what bills make it to the floor for a vote.

But House Republican Leader Kirk Cox told The Associated Press shortly after the drawing that if Simonds pursued a recount, neither Yancey or Simonds would be seated until a winner was finalized. That would still allow Republicans to elect a speaker and make committee assignments based on a 50-49 advantage.

However another race in Stafford County and Fredericksburg remains disputed and could alter the balance of power again. Democrats hope to block Republican Bob Thomas from being seated. A hearing is set for Friday in federal court.

WTOP’s Max Smith contributed to this report from Richmond. 

 


Like WTOP on Facebook and follow @WTOP on Twitter to engage in conversation about this article and others.

© 2018 WTOP. All Rights Reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

More from WTOP

Log in to your WTOP account for notifications and alerts customized for you.

Sign up