An MBA rejection email from your dream school can sting. But taking time to identify what your application is missing may help you succeed in the next admissions cycle.
“There are all sorts of reasons why an MBA applicant might have been rejected and you can drive yourself to distraction trying to figure out why,” says Barbara Coward, founder and principal at MBA 360 Admissions.
Common Reasons MBA Applicants Are Rejected
Admissions committees evaluate the full profile of an applicant, not just grades or test scores, experts say. One weak spot on your MBA application can potentially work against you, but multiple can really hurt your chances.
Most schools don’t explain why an applicant got rejected, and not every rejection makes sense to applicants, experts say.
“I’ve worked with clients who have been rejected from top-15 schools but subsequently accepted at much more competitive M7 schools in another round or cycle,” Coward says.
Still, it’s worth evaluating any red flags in your application, particularly if you plan to reapply. Here are eight reasons your application may have fallen short.
1. Essays That Feel Generic or Insincere
Admissions committees notice recycled personal statements that lack a clear and authentic voice, genuine motivation or individuality.
Essays should explain why applicants want an MBA, why now, and why that specific school, says Shaifali Aggarwal, founder and CEO of Ivy Groupe. “If your essays feel scattered or fail to connect your past experiences to your future goals, the application can come across as unfocused.”
[Read: How to Decide if an MBA Is Worth it]
Instead, ensure your goals are well defined, your motivations are genuine and your story is cohesive throughout every part of your application, Aggarwal says.
“Convince the admissions reader that you will bring more value into the program than the other applicants,” Coward says.
2. Unclear Career Goals or Inconsistent Narratives
Your candidacy can appear unfocused if your work history and future plans don’t provide a coherent story or if you can’t explain how an MBA fits in your life.
“Some applicants have unrealistic career goals,” says Laura Nelson, co-founder and MBA admissions consultant at MBA Pathfinders. “In this market, it’s important to present a career transition or pivot that is realistic. This demonstrates self-awareness across the application and interview.”
Present a clear, consistent story of how your past experience, MBA goals and future plans align. Explain your post-MBA path, how your background prepares you for it and how an MBA can strengthen gaps in skills, experts say.
3. Professional Experience Concerns
There is a sweet spot when applying to B-schools, experts say. Having too little experience may limit your classroom contributions, while too much can make you overqualified and hinder recruiting.
“If an applicant has too much or too little experience, the bar is going to be a bit higher when it comes to articulating why the candidate wants an MBA, what they plan to do with it and how they will contribute uniquely to the classroom,” says Scott Edinburgh, founder of Personal MBA Coach.
Assess whether your experience level meets the school’s expectations. Those with limited experience can reapply after gaining leadership roles, while overqualified candidates may want to consider part-time or executive MBA programs, experts say.
[READ: How to Decide Between a Full-Time and Part-Time MBA]
4. Limited Leadership Impact
Some candidates lack proof of leadership or initiative, such as inspiring or guiding others, and simply participate in projects.
“Be sure to show any leadership or initiative you’ve undertaken at work,” says Pamela Jaffe, co-founder and MBA admissions consultant at MBA Pathfinders. “It doesn’t have to be big, but it should be ownable. If you don’t have the opportunity at work, show this through your extracurriculars.”
5. Resumes That Read Like Job Descriptions
A MBA resume with buzzwords or corporate jargon that’s short on achievements is difficult for committees to gauge accomplishments.
“Many applicants have similar professional profiles, especially from fields like consulting, finance or tech. What sets you apart isn’t the title, it’s the impact and insight you’ve gained along the way,” Aggarwal says.
She advises students to reflect on what makes their leadership or perspective unique.
“Highlight personal growth, challenges overcome and moments that show your values in action,” Aggarwal says.
6. Lukewarm or Vague Recommendation Letters
Having strong recommendation letters can leave an impression on admissions committees.
Pick better recommenders that can support and vouch for you. Provide your recommender with detailed information about specific projects, outcomes and metrics so they can recommend you with enthusiasm, experts say.
7. Poor School Fit
Not explaining why a specific program aligns with your background and goals may come across as under-researched or disinterested.
“While business schools value authenticity in the application process, you also need to show that you would thrive in the program,” Coward says. “That means, for instance, if the business school has an emphasis on case study learning, you need to provide evidence that you will contribute to that learning environment.”
[Here are 5 Ways to Be a Competitive MBA Applicant]
School fit can come in many shapes and forms, Edinburgh says.
“Ensure that with every encounter you are demonstrating how you will be someone one would want to study with, work with or even live with,” Edinburgh says. “Be sure to check your ego at the door and treat every person you meet with respect and kindness.”
8. Academic or Testing Concerns
An applicant’s academic metrics matter a lot, experts say.
“Sometimes, the candidate’s stats — GPA or standardized test scores or both — just aren’t competitive,” Nelson says.
Applicants should review profiles from the current class to benchmark whether their scores and grades are competitive for a particular program.
“If they aren’t competitive, we recommend retaking the test, taking a different test or doing additional quant-based coursework,” Nelson says.
Whether to Apply Again
Reapplying can be worthwhile for students who have taken time to grow, reflect and clarify what’s changed since their last application, Aggarwal says.
“Admissions committees respect perseverance and reflection, especially when applicants show genuine growth and clearer self-awareness the second time around,” Aggarwal says.
MBA hopefuls should reevaluate the initial application and “determine what can be improved across test scores, coursework, school selection, networking with the program and students, and more,” Nelson says.
Think about career goals and determine if a MBA still makes sense — and if your goals align with market realities, Nelson says.
“You don’t have to wait until the next cycle, too,” Coward says. “I’ve encouraged applicants to apply to another school, or schools, in a later round where they were accepted and actually found a better fit.”
Even with a rejection, give yourself credit for applying, Coward says, since it shows ambition and confidence in your future.
“There are bruised egos, understandably, after getting a rejection,” Coward says. “Get right back on that horse.”
More from U.S. News
Tips for International Students Applying to Popular U.S. Graduate Programs
7 Critical Steps to Find the Right Grad School
What an MBA Degree Is and What You Need to Know
MBA Rejection: 8 Possible Reasons and What to Do originally appeared on usnews.com
