Hail to the Reese’s: Peanut-butter-and-chocolate combo dominates Crush-Off

WASHINGTON — October is candy lovers’ favorite month, so just imagine how big it is for the nice folks who make the stuff.

“This is like our Super Bowl,” said Lauren Aardewijn of Hershey’s Co.

Their Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are consistent favorites in that annual Super Bowl of candy. So perhaps it’s no surprise they just dominated a much bigger game: WTOP’s Candy Crush-Off 2017.

Reese’s stood tall in the chocolate division (24 percent) and stood even taller in overall competition (30 percent). The closest runner-up in each of those divisions was Mars Inc.’s Snicker’s bar (11 percent and 9 percent, respectively).

Those peanut butter cups actually outshined Mark Rypien’s Super Bowl XXVI performance.

The results came as no surprise to Aardewijn: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, she said, are among Hershey’s biggest Halloween sellers (along with Hershey’s Milk Chocolate bars and KitKats).

“It’s just this amazing combination of chocolate and peanut butter,” Aardewijn said. “It is just the perfect combo.”

In the non-chocolate division, Skittles (11 percent) edged out Candy Corn (10 percent).

Sour reaction

The results left some fans of other sweets a little sour. WTOP news and programming director  Mike McMearty, a toffee enthusiast, believed Heath and Skor deserved a fairer shake from voters, despite their apparent love affair with peanut butter.

“I love peanut butter as much as the next guy,” he said, “but I think Reese’s rise to prominence and popularity is due to aggressive marketing throughout the past few decades.”

“It does melt, it’s soft and, I believe, overrated.”

Another Skor aficionado, comedian Greg Behrendt, was taken aback that the winner lacked a certain ingredient.

“I’m surprised that there’s not something with caramel at the top,” he said.

The comedian (and America’s foremost candy thought leader) bemoaned what the survey shows about the state of candy in America.

“I think a country that allows itself to enjoy M&Ms peanut [No. 3 overall at 6 percent] doesn’t want candy at all,” he said.

OK. Let’s not let our emotions get the best of us. After all, it’s Oct. 31, we’re grown-ups, and we can have as much candy as we darn well please.

The final results are below. Happy Halloween!

Like WTOP on Facebook and follow @WTOP on Twitter to engage in conversation about this article and others.

© 2019 WTOP. All Rights Reserved. This website is not intended for users located within the European Economic Area.

More from WTOP

Log in to your WTOP account for notifications and alerts customized for you.

Sign up