Shop around for pet food in the D.C. area and you might find savings up to 40%. But paying higher prices can have advantages, a local based consumers group finds.
Washington Consumers’ Checkbook compared prices of 11 popular dog and cat foods at pet stores, big-box discounters, grocery stores, warehouse clubs and online suppliers.
“Some stores charge 40 percent more than others for the exact same stuff,” said Kevin Brasler, executive editor at Checkbook.org.
Who is cheapest?
“We found the lowest prices probably where you’d expect — at Sam’s Club, at BJ’s and at Walmart,” Brasler said. Costco wasn’t included in the box-store comparison because it doesn’t sell mass market brands.
Compared to the all-store average:
- Sam’s Club was 26% lower;
- BJ’s, 18% lower;
- Walmart, 17% lower.
Which big pet-store chain has the best prices? Compared to the all-store average, PetSmart was 5% lower, while Petco was about the average.
Compared to the lowest priced local stores, PetSmart’s prices were about 20% higher, and Petco’s prices were about 25% higher. If you order pet food online and have it shipped to either store for pickup, Petco offers a 10% discount, while PetSmart’s discount is 5 percent.
What about independent shops?
“At the independent stores, one advantage is, you’re likely to get good advice on what to buy. And that’s key,” Brasler said. “The specialty stores that really have a lot of expertise can tell you what might work best.”
The food at independent stores might include more protein so you can feed your pet less, Brasler said, “as opposed to one of the mass market brands that might have a lot of filler in it. So this is actually something worth considering talking to your vet about.”
What about online?
“Amazon had far higher prices than the lower price local stores,” Brasler said. “And it had higher prices than a lot of its online-only competitors.”
The lowest prices Checkbook found online were at Chewy.com, which weren’t much higher than Sam’s Club and BJ’s.
Chewy.com prices were 16% lower than those at Amazon for the same products, Checkbook found.
Through a special arrangement with Washington Consumers’ Checkbook, WTOP.com readers can see Checkbook price comparisons on pet food for a limited time.
Consumers’ Checkbook/Center for the Study of Services is an independent, nonprofit consumer organization founded in 1974. It provides information to help consumers make smarter choices.