Click to toggle navigation menu.
Headlines
Local News
Click to expand menu.
Virginia
Click to expand menu.
Alexandria
Arlington
Fairfax County
Loudoun County
Prince William County
Stafford County
Maryland
Click to expand menu.
Anne Arundel County
Baltimore
Calvert County
Charles County
Frederick County
Howard County
Montgomery County
Prince George's County
DC
Crime News
Matt About Town
Weather News
Transportation News
National
Click to expand menu.
National Security
Election 2024
Click to expand menu.
DC Elections
Maryland Elections
Virginia Elections
World
Business & Finance
Click to expand menu.
Consumer
Real Estate
Recalls
Government
Click to expand menu.
Congress
Supreme Court
White House
Blog: Today on the Hill
Lifestyle
Click to expand menu.
Animals & Pets
Food & Restaurants
Health & Fitness
Life & Style
Parenting
Travel
Entertainment
Sports
Click to expand menu.
Baltimore Orioles
Baltimore Ravens
DC United
Washington Capitals
Washington Mystics
Washington Nationals
Washington Commanders
Washington Wizards
Science
Click to expand menu.
The Space Place
Photo Galleries
WTOP Noticias
Advertise on WTOP
Federal News Network
Fun & Games
WTOP Insights
Click to collapse navigation menu.
News
Traffic
Weather
site search query
Live Radio
Listen Live
Login
Home
»
Latest News
»
Best Picture Battle
Best Picture Battle
WTOP Staff
|
WTOP_Web_Team@wtop.com
February 21, 2013, 1:43 PM
Share This:
share on facebook
share on X
share on threads
share on linkedin
share on email
print
WTOP Film Critic Jason Fraley gives his best case for and against each Best Picture nominee.
Listen now to WTOP News
WTOP.com | Alexa | Google Home | WTOP App | 103.5 FM
'Zero Dark Thirty'
Why It Could Win:
"Zero Dark Thirty" was the top rated nominee among the critics (95 percent Metacritic). It was also named Best Film by the National Board of Review, Writers Guild of America (Original Screenplay) and the critics associations of Austin, Boston, Chicago, New York, San Francisco, Vancouver and Washington D.C.
Why It Won't Win:
Kathryn Bigelow was already given Best Picture three years ago for "The Hurt Locker." Expect the Academy to look elsewhere, especially due to the film's lengthy tradecraft and political controversy.
'Beasts of the Southern Wild'
Why It Could Win:
Director Benh Zeitlin's mix of child fantasy and gritty reality dominated the indie circuit, winning the Grand Jury Prize at Sundance, the Golden Camera at Cannes and Best First Feature at the Toronto Film Festival.
Why It Won't Win:
Sundance winners have never won the Oscar for Best Picture, from "Blood Simple" to "Winter's Bone," and first-time filmmakers rarely win Best Picture, with rare exceptions like Sam Mendes for "American Beauty" (1999).
'Amour'
Why It Could Win:
"Amour" was the international art favorite, winning cinema's top art prize (Palme d'Or) at the Cannes Film Festival and Best Picture by the National Society of Film Critics, European Film Awards and Los Angeles Film Critics Association. It also won Best Foreign Language Film at the Golden Globes, BAFTA, Broadcast Film Critics Association, National Board of Review and the film critic associations of Boston, Chicago, Dallas, Kansas City, Las Vegas, New York, San Francisco, Toronto and Washington D.C.
Why It Won't Win:
The Academy tends to relegate foreign films to the Best Foreign Language category and forget about them for Best Picture, except for last year's "The Artist" (2011), which avoided subtitles with its silent gimmick.
'Django: Unchained'
Why It Could Win:
Quentin Tarantino's slave revenge tale was the online fan favorite with the highest IMDB rating (8.6) of this year's nominees. It also was the second highest grossing among the Best Picture nominees, behind only "Lincoln," and its script was acclaimed at the Golden Globes, BAFTA and Broadcast Film Critics Association.
Why It Won't Win:
Like "Zero Dark Thirty," the film is laced with controversy, in this case, excessive violence and language. Tarantino may be a darling among list makers ("Pulp Fiction" makes many a Top 10), but he has yet to land Best Picture with the Academy.
'Life of Pi'
Why It Could Win:
Ang Lee's vision made "Life of Pi" a wonder to behold for all ages, so much that it was chosen as Best Picture by the Las Vegas Film Critics Society. It was also the most visually stunning movie of the year, taking 3D graphics to new heights.
Why It Won't Win:
Special effects titans are often nominated, but rarely win (i.e. "Star Wars"). No 3D film has ever won Best Picture, putting "Life of Pi" in the recent class with "Avatar" and "Hugo" as losing Best Picture nominees.
'Les Miserables'
Why It Could Win:
"Les Miserables" was custom built for Oscar glory: a legendary stage musical, packed with stars and directed by past Best Picture winner Tom Hooper ("The King's Speech"). It also won Best Picture (Comedy/Musical) at the Golden Globes.
Why It Won't Win:
Only one musical ("Chicago") has won Best Picture since 1968, and this year's Golden Globe win came against weak Comedy/Musical competition. The film will also suffer from its niche following, with fans adoring the soundtrack, and haters finding the three-hour slog akin to the torture scenes from "Zero Dark Thirty."
'Silver Linings Playbook'
Why It Could Win:
David O. Russell's dramedy was a crowd pleaser, winning Audience Awards at the Toronto and Austin Film Festivals. It also won Best Comedy by the Broadcast Film Critics Association, Capri Movie of the Year and Best Picture at the Satellite Awards.
Why It Won't Win:
The film was a bipolar movie about bipolar disorder, starting off as a gritty tale of pill-popping therapy, then shifting toward "Dirty Dancing" rom-com cliches. The shift appears intentional, as Bradley Cooper's bashes Hemingway ("Why can't there be more happy endings?"), but it's too polarizing for Best Picture.
'Lincoln'
Why It Could Win:
"Lincoln" was the war horse that jumped out early and faded down the stretch. The film boasts the most Oscar nominations (12), the best box office showing and the most teachable moments. Such is the appeal of Spielberg. "Lincoln" is the closest thing to his sole Best Picture, "Schindler's List" (1993), and if Euclid holds true ("Things that are equal to the same thing are also equal to each other"), it could be the year of "Lincoln." Expect a photo finish, as Oscar voters made their picks throughout President Obama's re-election, Inauguration, Black History Month and Presidents Day.
Why It Won't Win:
The film has faltered during award season, with its only Best Pictures coming from the Dallas-Forth Worth Critics Association and the Florida Film Critics Circle. Perhaps it would have done better without its sentimental opening and overwrought ending that should have ended with Lincoln's walk to his Ford's Theater carriage. Academy voters may check their "Lincoln" box by giving Daniel-Day Lewis Best Actor (a lock), and casting their Best Picture votes to the underdog.
'Argo'
Why It Will Win:
"Argo" is more than just a Benghazi zeitgeist film, it's a classic celebration of how Hollywood imagination can shape world events. Thus, it captures our heads and our hearts. On the critic side, "Argo" has quietly held the highest rating on Rotten Tomatoes (96%) of any of the nominees. On the public side, it's one of just three ("Django," "Life of Pi") to have an IMDB rating of at least 8.0. This crossover appeal is the same blend of artistic skill and popular entertainment that allowed "Rocky" to upset "Network," "Taxi Driver" and "All the President's Men" (1976).
Immediately after Ben Affleck's snubbing for Best Director, the hand of cinema fate has continually bent toward "Argo," winning the top prize at the Golden Globes, SAG Awards, Broadcast Film Critics Association and the WGA. Expect "Argo" to ride the Oscar tidal wave all the way to Best Picture, as the underdog Affleck has earned the right to take the stage and deliver his film's trademark line: "Argo, f*ck yourself."
(
1
/9)
Share This Gallery:
Share This:
share on facebook
share on X
share on threads
share on linkedin
share on email
print
Related News
Haiti health system nears collapse as medicine dwindles, gangs attack hospitals and ports stay shut
Myanmar’s ousted leader Suu Kyi moved from prison to house arrest due to heat, military says
Supreme Court allows Idaho to enforce its ban on gender-affirming care for transgender youth
Recommended
Prince George's Co. to enforce youth curfew at National Harbor starting Friday
Israel-Hamas protests: George Washington University wants student encampment cleared by 7 p.m.
3 killed in 3 separate shootings in less than 2-hour span across DC
Related Categories:
Entertainment News
|
Latest News
Log in to your WTOP account for notifications and alerts customized for you.
Sign up
LOGOUT
VIEW PROFILE