A breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the National League.
| Name, Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | |
| Jason Foster, The Sporting News | ATL | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Paul Newberry, The Associated Press | ATL | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Meg Rowley, FanGraphs | AZ | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Zach Buchanan, The Athletic | AZ | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Gordon Wittenmyer, NBC Sports Chicago | CHI | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Eugen McIntosh, The Bigs Media | CHI | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Matt Snyder, CBS Sports | CIN | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Dan Szymborski, FanGraphs | CIN | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Manny Randhawa, MLB.com | COL | Harris | II | Strider | McCarthy |
| Kevin Henry, Rox Pile | COL | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Jim Alexander, Southern California News Group | LA | Harris | II | Diaz | Cruz |
| Alden Gonzalez, ESPN | LA | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Jon Heyman, MLB Network | MIA | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Mari Montes, El Extrabase | MIA | Harris | II | Strider | Cruz |
| Andrew Wagner, Forbes Sports | MIL | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Drew Olson, iHeart Media Milwaukee | MIL | Strider | Harris | II | Lodolo |
| Deesha Thosar, Fox Sports | NY | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Will Sammon, The Athletic | NY | Harris | II | Strider | McCarthy |
| Keith Law, The Athletic | PHI | Strider | Harris | II | McCarthy |
| Corey Seidman, NBC Sports Philadelphia | PHI | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Justice delos Santos, MLB.com | PIT | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Jason Mackey, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette | PIT | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Kyle Glaser, Baseball America | SD | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| John Maffei, Union-Tribune | SD | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Maria Guardado, MLB.com | SF | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Evan Webeck, Bay Area News Group | SF | Harris | II | Strider | McCarthy |
| Benjamin Hochman, St. Louis Post-Dispatch | STL | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
| Jeff Jones, Belleville News-Democrat | STL | Strider | Harris | II | Donovan |
| Brittany Ghiroli, The Athletic | WAS | Harris | II | Strider | Lodolo |
| Joe Trezza, MLB.com | WAS | Harris | II | Strider | Donovan |
Copyright © 2024 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.
