A breakdown of the 30 individual ballots, submitted by two writers representing each city in the National League.
| Name, Affiliation | Chapter | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| Charles Odum, The Associated Press | ATL | India | Rogers | Anderson |
| Mark Bowman, MLB.com | ATL | India | Rogers | Anderson |
| Jack Magruder, Forbes | AZ | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Jesse Sanchez, MLB.com | AZ | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Sahadev SHarma, The Athletic | CHI | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Gordon Wittenmyer, NBC Sports Chicago | CHI | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Dan Szymborski, FanGraphs | CIN | Rogers | India | Schwindel |
| Hal McCoy, Dayton Daily News | CIN | India | Rogers | Stephenson |
| Manny Randhawa, MLB.com | COL | India | Carlson | Rogers |
| Kevin Henry, Rox Pile | COL | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Joe Reedy, The Associated Press | LA | India | Rogers | Wisdom |
| Brian Golden, Antelope Valley Press | LA | India | Rogers | Wisdom |
| Christina De Nicola, MLB.com | MIA | India | Rogers | Stephenson |
| Jorge Ebro, El Nueve Herald | MIA | India | Rogers | Gutierrez |
| Drew Olson, iHeart Media Milwaukee | MIL | India | Rogers | Wisdom |
| Joel Sherman, New York Post | MIL | India | Rogers | Anderson |
| Tim Britton, The Athletic | NY | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Anthony DiComo, MLB.com | NY | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Jayson Stark, The Athletic | PHI | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Mike McGarry, Press of Atlantic City | PHI | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Alex Stumpf, DK Pittsburgh Sports | PIT | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Rob Biertempfel, The Atlantic | PIT | India | Rogers | Bednar |
| Kyle Glaser, Baseball America | SD | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Bryce Miller, San Diego Union Tribune | SD | India | Rogers | Wisdom |
| Kerry Crowley, San Jose Mercury News | SF | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Grant Brisbee, The Athletic | SF | India | Rogers | Schwindel |
| Ben Frederickson, St. Louis Post-Dispatch | STL | India | Carlson | Rogers |
| Rob Rains, STL SportsPage.com | STL | India | Carlson | Rogers |
| Jessica Camerato, MLB.com | WAS | India | Rogers | Carlson |
| Brittany Ghiroli, The Athletic | WAS | India | Rogers | Carlson |
Copyright © 2024 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, written or redistributed.
