RICHMOND, Va. - The Virginia Supreme Court has revived a legal battle between coal companies that has been fought over the last 15 years in courts in Virginia and West Virginia.
The justices unanimously ruled Thursday that a Buchanan County judge erred when he dismissed a lawsuit against Richmond-based Massey Energy. Hugh Caperton claims his companies were financially damaged when Massey slashed the amount of coal it had agreed to buy.
A West Virginia jury in 2002 awarded $50 million to Caperton, but that verdict has been rejected three times by the West Virginia Supreme Court. The case was shifted to Virginia, where a judge said the issues had already been resolved by previous rulings. The Virginia Supreme Court disagreed, ruling that he issues in the Virginia filing are different.
Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.